Could we start again, please? Good Friday with Paul Thomas


Deep-Throating the Saints

Paul Thomas

It’s fun to know that Dana DeArmond used to work at Disney World and, of course, there’s Maitland Ward, another Disney alum who shamelessly doubled-down in porn. But even if Disney is a certified porn pipeline (and we can add the “Pirates of the Caribbean”-to-“Pirates” movies), my favorite porn crossover story is from a simpler time, when Paul Thomas made the smooth transition from Broadway actor to adult star during the early 70s Porno Chic era.

(This is a reprinted article from the vast Porn Valley Observed archives.)

Whenever I see Paul Thomas, who went from a Broadway career in generation-defining musicals like “Hair” to a 4-decade (and counting) gig in front of and behind the camera in porn, I ask him about the middle period: his role as Peter in the 1973 Norman Jewison movie “Jesus Christ Superstar.”

PT with Yvonne Elliman in 1973, and with Monique Alexander and Stefani Morgan in 2006
PT with Yvonne Elliman in 1973, and with Monique Alexander and Stefani Morgan in 2006

Several years ago, when Thomas was shooting “Debbie Does Dallas Again” for Vivid and participating in a Showtime/World of Wonder Making Of special, he told me about how the “Superstar” cast had spent its downtime in Israel’s Negev Desert.

“Yvonne Elliman (Mary Magdalene) had just seen ‘Deep Throat’ but wanted to know what one was like,” he said. “So we went off to the desert and she practiced her deep throating techniques on some of the, er, saints.”

This remains one of my favorite quotes. Thomas (who was credited as Philip Toubus in the movie) and I had another conversation in Las Vegas in which he elaborated on that time in his life and its relationship to the next chapter.

“It was fabulous,” he said. “Incredible fun. I was a star. You’re often not aware at the time about how cool something is. But I was. ‘Hair’ and ‘Jesus Christ Superstar’ were the apex of my culture. I was in this world. I was very aware that I was way ahead of my curve. (He pauses for five seconds) Then I got into porno and jumped to the back of the class.”

Since parting ways with Vivid in 2009, Thomas has directed fewer movies, but outings like 2010’s “Pervert” are more up his alley.

“I never liked ‘Happy People Having Happy Sex,'” he told me. “I was a swinger in the 1970s and I would go to these clubs stag. People would know who I was, whether through porno or whatever, and men would come up to me with their girlfriends and say, ‘Can you fuck my wife?’

“I would say, ‘Would you like to watch? It’s gonna be completely OK?’ and he’d say, ‘Oh, it’s wonderful! We love you!’ And I’d say No.

“It would be the times when the husband was hiding in the closet, [chastising] himself, and the wife would berate him because I had a bigger dick than him, and then go home and beat him later…Then I was interested. I like the darker side. It’s not a Wicked movie.”

I asked Thomas what had changed between the 70s and now, if that was a question he could answer. Was there a throughline to people attracted to the adult industry?

“It’s not universal,” he said, but added: “They’re good looking, sexually liberal and curious, politically unconscious, in some sort of denial about their life…what is universal, I guess, is conflict.”

In “Jesus Christ Superstar,” Thomas’s character denies Jesus Christ three times on Good Friday. Then, in a fantasy sequence written for the movie (and Academy Award consideration, as “Superstar” was adapted from a musical), Thomas sings “Could We Start Again, Please?” with Elliman and Ted Neeley’s Jesus.

I asked Thomas if he would start again in porn, knowing what he knows now.

“Not in this century,” he said.

  • Buy “Pervert” here

Previously on Porn Valley Observed: Paul Thomas Superstar; Is the feature dead?

About Gram the Man 4399 Articles
Gram Ponante is America's Beloved Porn Journalist

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.